(Download) "United Parcel Service Inc. v. Flores-Galarza" by First Circuit U.S. Court Of Appeals # Book PDF Kindle ePub Free
eBook details
- Title: United Parcel Service Inc. v. Flores-Galarza
- Author : First Circuit U.S. Court Of Appeals
- Release Date : January 04, 2003
- Genre: Law,Books,Professional & Technical,
- Pages : * pages
- Size : 79 KB
Description
The Commonwealth of Puerto Rico has enacted a statutory regime that prohibits an interstate air carrier from delivering any package unless the carrier first provides proof that the package's addressee has paid the appropriate excise tax, or the carrier prepays the amount of the tax on the addressee's behalf. Plaintiffs United Parcel Service, Inc., and United Parcel Service, Co., (collectively ""UPS"") persuaded the district court to enjoin the Commonwealth's Treasury Secretary from enforcing these delivery restrictions on the grounds of federal preemption. The parties have filed cross-appeals which raise difficult questions about the lawfulness and proper scope of the injunction in light of arguably conflicting federal statutes that, on the one hand, strip the district court of jurisdiction to entertain suits seeking to restrain the collection of any Puerto Rico tax and authorize the Commonwealth to exercise taxing jurisdiction over packages as soon as they enter the island, and, on the other hand, limit the Commonwealth's ability to regulate an air carrier's service. In the end, we affirm the court's central ruling but remand for reconsideration of several peripheral matters. Before us, Defendant Juan A. Flores-Galarza, in his official capacity as the Secretary of the Department of the Treasury of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (the ""Secretary""), contends that the district court erred in finding that it had jurisdiction over the controversy, that Puerto Rico's restrictions on delivery were preempted by federal law, and that an administrative fine imposed by the Secretary was invalid and unenforceable. The Secretary also makes an alternative argument that the injunction is overbroad. UPS's cross-appeal challenges the district court's exclusion from the scope of the injunction a statutory provision requiring the payment of license fees by air carriers.
 "United Parcel Service Inc. v. Flores-Galarza" by First Circuit U.S. Court Of Appeals # Book PDF Kindle ePub Free){kind=link}